What Makes a New Card Win the Wallet?
New data reveals that digital ease of use, rather than just rewards, determines which financing products customers use repeatedly.
Curated by Financing Your Way from original reporting by PYMNTS. Summary is AI-assisted and editorially reviewed — see our editorial standards.
This report highlights a critical shift in consumer behavior: the 'top-of-wallet' status is no longer just about interest rates. It is now decided by the initial digital experience. For retailers offering branded credit cards or financing programs, the friction a customer feels during the first 30 days determines if they will become a loyal repeat user or if they will abandon the card after a single purchase. The data shows that 42% of consumers consider ease of use the most important factor when choosing which card to use for a transaction. For operators, this means the 'unboxing' of a new financial product must be seamless. If a customer has to jump through hoops to activate a digital card or integrate it into their mobile wallet, the lifetime value of that customer plummets. Merchants should evaluate their lending partners based on their mobile integration capabilities. Features like instant issuance—allowing a customer to use their new credit line immediately at checkout via their phone—are becoming the baseline expectation. If your financing partner still relies on physical mailers and manual activation, you are likely losing out on repeat sales and long-term customer engagement.
Source: PYMNTS
Related coverage from across the industry
- Where platforms are losing (and winning) merchants: Inside switching triggersPayments Dive · Oct 12, 2026Read our summary →
- How brands can capitalize on post-Fall Prime Day momentumModern Retail · Oct 10, 2026Read our summary →
- CFOs Risk Losing Control of Working Capital One Sales Contract at a TimePYMNTS · Oct 8, 2026Read our summary →
- 5 Ways Missing Payment Options Send Shoppers ElsewherePYMNTS · Oct 7, 2026Read our summary →
- At Home gives its customers a voice in its loyalty program evolutionRetail Dive · Sep 23, 2026Read our summary →
- Gen Z Hands Merchants a Checkout UltimatumPYMNTS · Sep 23, 2026Read our summary →
